diff options
Diffstat (limited to 'research/LSA2006-abstract.rst')
-rw-r--r-- | research/LSA2006-abstract.rst | 67 |
1 files changed, 67 insertions, 0 deletions
diff --git a/research/LSA2006-abstract.rst b/research/LSA2006-abstract.rst new file mode 100644 index 0000000..3920952 --- /dev/null +++ b/research/LSA2006-abstract.rst @@ -0,0 +1,67 @@ +The Discovery of Discourse; The Heroic Struggle of the Boston Minorities to belong among “Us” and not “Them” +############################################################################################################ + +:category: research +:date: 2006-02-19T23:00:00 +:tags: boston, murders, policing, criminology + +{abstract prepared for the Annual Meeting of the Law & Society +Association} + +The dramatic decrease in murder rate in the City of Boston in the late +1990s (so called “The Boston Miracle”) was explained by many researchers +in many different ways and therefore seen as a result of many different +actions of different actors. So, for example, `Winship (2002)`_ +explained The Boston Miracle as result of the cooperation between The +Ten Point Coalition (a coalition of local mostly Black churches) and the +authorities of the City of Boston (esp. police, social and youth +services), where Black ministers functioned as the mediating factor +which provided an “umbrella of legitimacy” for BPD strategies, which +could otherwise be understood as the use of excessive force against the +minority community. At the same time the ministers provided valuable +information for the police about the most troublemaking elements in the +minority community. This story has now returned to the predominant +position in the press and media, because of the 2004-05 rise of the +murder rate again to the highest level in the ten years. + +On the other hand, the project of police operation created by the team +around the Harvard professors David Kennedy and Anthony Braga `(Braga, +Kennedy, 2001)`_ was labelled by many others as the main cause of the +successful crime prevention. And there are many other contenders (less +influential and less visible ones) to claim the credit (for example, The +Nation of Islam was credited by the local African-American community +newspaper as the most influential factor in the decrease of crime). And +of course, local politicians (whether African-American, Latino, or +white) claimed their credit as well. + +In view of the number and persuasiveness of different theories +explaining The Boston Miracle, I do not want to add yet another +all-explaining theory, because I think that the whole success of the +Bostonian anti-crime policy of the late 1990s has multiple causes which +mutually enforced each other and lead to the final success. On the other +hand, I would like to suggest one more point of view on the whole +history which could conveniently bind together many of these +explanations. Symbolic interactionism `(Blumer, 1969)`_ explains the +development of self-understanding as a by-product of the interaction +between different actors and in the same moment predicts that the +expected behavior can be linked to the actor’s self-perception generated +in the past interactions `(Mead, 1934)`_. + +The purpose of this research is to understand one particular aspect of +this self-perception at the level of the community, and that is division +into “Us” and “Them” between minority and majority actors. Analysis of +the newspaper articles will be used to find out how much narrowing (or +widening) of the gap between majority and the official establishment on +the one side and minority communities on the other side made their +mutual collaboration possible. Emphasis will be put on the relationship +between long-term processes (as the redefinition of the community self +is) and short-term consequences of changes during these processes. + +.. _`Winship (2002)`: + http://www.wjh.harvard.edu/soc/faculty/winship/End_of_a_Miracle.pdf +.. _`(Braga, Kennedy, 2001)`: + http://jrc.sagepub.com/cgi/content/abstract/38/3/195 +.. _`(Blumer, 1969)`: + http://worldcatlibraries.org/wcpa/isbn/0520056760 +.. _`(Mead, 1934)`: + http://www.worldcatlibraries.org/wcpa/ow/357fd970b6b590f8.html |