diff options
Diffstat (limited to '.be/bugs/529c290e-b1cf-4800-be7e-68f1ecb9565c/comments/ea01c122-e629-4d5c-afa7-b180f4a8748b')
2 files changed, 0 insertions, 86 deletions
diff --git a/.be/bugs/529c290e-b1cf-4800-be7e-68f1ecb9565c/comments/ea01c122-e629-4d5c-afa7-b180f4a8748b/body b/.be/bugs/529c290e-b1cf-4800-be7e-68f1ecb9565c/comments/ea01c122-e629-4d5c-afa7-b180f4a8748b/body deleted file mode 100644 index fce4941..0000000 --- a/.be/bugs/529c290e-b1cf-4800-be7e-68f1ecb9565c/comments/ea01c122-e629-4d5c-afa7-b180f4a8748b/body +++ /dev/null @@ -1,72 +0,0 @@ -On Tue, Jul 14, 2009 at 10:36:26PM +1000, Ben Finney wrote: -> "W. Trevor King" <wking@drexel.edu> writes: -> > I've switched my branch over to the current url, and moved to -> > last-commit-timestamp version numbers. -> -> Please, no. Timestamps aren't version strings, that's conflating two -> pieces of information with very different meanings. Correlating the two -> is the job of a changelog. - -Which we don't bother keeping (also NEWS), since "bzr log" works so nicely. -If you really want an standard changelog, see - http://mail.gnome.org/archives/desktop-devel-list/2007-September/msg00186.html - -> > This removes the "prefered branch" issues with the old scheme, and -> > version numbers should increase monotonically -> -> The English word “should” is ambiguous in this context. Are you saying -> this is desirable, or are you predicting that it will likely be the -> case? - -Both. - -> I don't see how it's either, so am doubly confused :-) - -The timestamp should at least replace the patch release number, which -you agree is-desirable-to increase motonically ;). I also predict -that it will increase monotonically for any given branch, since the -branch HEAD will have both the most recent commit and the highest -version number. The only problem I can think of is having your clock -_way_ off, and that is unlikely enough to ignore. If you hop between -branches, the timestamp is much more likely to increase going to the -more modern branch than the bzr revision number, which desynchronize -between branches fairly quickly. - -> The convention for three-part version strings is often: -> -> * Major release number (big changes in how the program works, -> increasing monotonically per major release, with “0”indicating no -> major release yet) -> -> * Minor release number (smaller impact on how the program works, -> increasing monotonically per minor release, with “0” indicating no -> minor release yet since the previous major) -> -> * Patch release number (bug-fix and other changes that don't affect -> the documented interface, increasing monotonically per patch -> release, with “0” indicating no patch release since the previous -> major or minor) - -One problem is that we don't actually have "releases". People just -clone a branch, install, and go. If you're worried about stability, -just clone from a more stable branch (i.e., Chris' trunk). I think -this is good for distributed development, but maybe makes it hard to -package into a conventional release-based system. With the bzr patch -number in setup.py as the patch release number, I would be releasing -my 0.1.363 while Chris releases his 0.1.314, even though they're at -about the same point. I would rather be releasing my - 0.1.20090714121347 -while Chris releases his - 0.1.20090713154540 -Since then the similarity is clearer. - -At any rate, I think the two approaches are close enough that an -auto-updating timestamp beats a manually bumped patch number, since -no-one ever actually bumps the patch number ;). - --- -This email may be signed or encrypted with GPG (http://www.gnupg.org). -The GPG signature (if present) will be attached as 'signature.asc'. -For more information, see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pretty_Good_Privacy - -My public key is at http://www.physics.drexel.edu/~wking/pubkey.txt diff --git a/.be/bugs/529c290e-b1cf-4800-be7e-68f1ecb9565c/comments/ea01c122-e629-4d5c-afa7-b180f4a8748b/values b/.be/bugs/529c290e-b1cf-4800-be7e-68f1ecb9565c/comments/ea01c122-e629-4d5c-afa7-b180f4a8748b/values deleted file mode 100644 index a3f74c4..0000000 --- a/.be/bugs/529c290e-b1cf-4800-be7e-68f1ecb9565c/comments/ea01c122-e629-4d5c-afa7-b180f4a8748b/values +++ /dev/null @@ -1,14 +0,0 @@ -Alt-id: <20090714133732.GB6160@mjolnir.home.net> - - -Author: W. Trevor King <wking@drexel.edu> - - -Content-type: text/plain - - -Date: Tue, 14 Jul 2009 09:37:32 -0400 - - -In-reply-to: 744435b7-1521-4059-a55d-f0c403d7b4d8 - |